I have, over the years, had a pretty weird relationship with Louise Erdrich’s books. I read a couple back in college and found them both pretty lacking. When The Round House won the National Book Award I picked it up and found that I liked it more than the previous ones I’d read, but I was still oddly chilly on it; I more admired it than really appreciated it. But then a book club I was in read The Last Report on the Miracles at Little-No-Horse and I was absolutely floored by it. Spurred by that experience I picked up and read The Sentence and found it to also be a really fantastic novel. So I’ve read five of her novels and my reactions run the gamut from forgettable and mediocre to absolute masterpiece. So make of that what you will.
The Mighty Red slots neatly into the middle of my rankings. I’d put it well above The Round House, but below The Sentence and Last Report. It’s probably the first of her novels on which I’m just kind of generally positive but not excitedly so. I tend to run either hot or cold, so this one is kind of the first one I’m just basically warm on.
The book is set in the Red River Valley in North Dakota during the economic downturn of 2008 and it follows a set of characters that are more or less successfully compelling. The main character is high school senior Kismet Poe who finds herself in a bit of an erstwhile love triangle between Gary Geist, the scion of a wealthy farming family, and Hugo, a home-schooled oil-field worker. But this isn’t a YA kind of love triangle and Erdrich’s prose is on point here. I found Kismet and Gary to be the most compelling characters. Kismet is a young woman on the cusp of adulthood but the world has nothing to offer her in the way of hope. Her father has disappeared with the local church’s building fund and her mother is dealing with that, so her family situation has her in a position of serious pressure. Gary is a character you might expect to be a kind of shallow villain, but he’s not; he’s deeply traumatized due to a horrific snowmobile incident that brutally killed his best friend and left him seriously injured and he’s wrestling with the notion that his status as a kind of local “golden child” is really meaningless when it comes down to matters of life and death.
I found some of the supporting characters to be less well developed and the subplot about the missing church building fund didn’t really go anywhere. But when Kismet and Gary were center stage, the book was compelling and often really heartbreaking. And, as you might expect with Erdrich, the ending is too complex to be happy, though it isn’t hopeless either. This isn’t Erdrich at the top of her game, but it’s a fine effort. 3 stars.
tl;dr – boasting beautiful prose and some compelling characters, this book still sits among Erdrich’s mid-range, not among her very best. 3 stars.